Home › Categories › Law & Legal› Concurrence

Concurrence.pdf

2018-04-13.hecht.pdf

🔗 Source: docs.texasappellate.com

📊 Size: 11 KB

👤 Author: OMcCarthy

⬇️ Downloads: 75

Summary

Chief Justice Hecht concurs in the judgment, joining parts of JUSTICE BOYD's and JUSTICE GREEN's opinions, but for different reasons. The Court unanimously disagrees with USAA and Menchaca that the jury answers do not conflict. Hecht agrees that the trial court erred in rendering judgment for Menchaca due to fatally conflicting jury answers, but disagrees with JUSTICE BOYD that an objection was necessary for reversal, as USAA could not object without contradicting its position. Hecht believes a retrial is necessary to correct the trial court's error, given the conflicting jury answers, and joins in the Court's judgment remanding the case to the trial court for further proceedings.

Download File

Description

Chief Justice Hecht concurs in the judgment, joining parts of JUSTICE BOYD's and JUSTICE GREEN's opinions, but for different reasons.

Technical Information

File Format: PDF
File Size: 11 KB
Pages: 3
Language: EN
Author: OMcCarthy
Total Downloads: 75
Last Updated: 4 weeks ago

Document Overview

This PDF document about Concurrence provides comprehensive information and guidance. Whether you're a beginner or advanced user, this resource offers valuable insights into Concurrence.