'Requested Review'.pdf

bgd-10-C6078-2013.pdf
Preview of 'Requested review'
🔗 Source: bg.copernicus.org
📊 Size: 586 KB
📄 Pages: 4 pages
⬇️ Downloads: 277

Summary

presents results from an experiment examining the effects of different types of calcite on particle formation and sinking speeds, addressing the biological carbon pump and the 'ballast' effect. The study found that coccoliths increased sinking speed, while whole tests of foraminifera broke up aggregates and failed to incorporate material. The manuscript is well-written, but two issues arise: discrepancies between aggregate size and foraminifera tests, and the use of 'clean' calcite lacking associated organic matter. The referee suggests discussing these factors and considering a repeat experiment with 'dirty' calcite sources. Specific comments include referencing, terminology, and methodology, such as the justification for picking particles >1mm and the potential for dissolution of material during PIC analysis.

Description

presents results from an experiment examining the effects of different types of calcite on particle formation and sinking speeds, addressing the biological...

Technical Information

  • File Format: PDF
  • File Size: 586 KB
  • Pages: 4
  • Language: EN
  • Total Downloads: 277
  • Last Updated: 4 hours ago

Document Overview

This PDF document about 'Requested review' provides comprehensive information and guidance. Whether you're a beginner or advanced user, this resource offers valuable insights into 'Requested review'.

Related Topics

If you're interested in 'Requested review', you might also want to explore:

Download 'Requested review' eBooks for free and learn more about 'Requested review'. These books contain exercises and tutorials to improve your practical skills, at all levels!

Not satisfied with this document? We have related documents to 'Requested review', try searching with similar keywords: 'Requested review', Requested Building Wireless Sensor Networks By Ro, Requested Linear Algebra With Applications 4th Ed, 200 Most Requested Songs, Actions Requested On SF 52, Address Service Requested, Address Service Requested Bethel United Methodist Church, Address Service Requested Fee

You can download PDF versions of the user's guide, manuals and ebooks about 'Requested review', you can also find and download for free A free online manual (notices) with beginner and intermediate, Downloads Documentation, You can download PDF files (or DOC and PPT) about 'Requested review' for free, but please respect copyrighted ebooks.