Home › Categories › Science & Nature› Peer Review File

Peer Review File.pdf

41467_2017_1797_MOESM2_ESM.pdf

🔗 Source: static-content.springer.com

📊 Size: 324 KB

👤 Author: Wilhelmsen, Charlotte

⬇️ Downloads: 208

Summary

Reviewer #1 criticizes the authors' claim that their supramolecular networks can passivate the BP surface and prevent degradation for up to 3 months, citing lack of experimental evidence to support this claim. They suggest that the authors should have used higher tip force to scratch through the coating and measure the surface under it to verify the preservation of BP. Reviewer #1 also points out that the authors have not discussed the effect of the EtOH solution used in sample preparation on the cleavage of BP layers.

Reviewer #2 recommends accepting the manuscript with minor revisions, suggesting rephrasing of technical descriptions and correcting grammatical errors. They also suggest considering halogen bonding as an alternative non-covalent interaction for future work.

Reviewer #3 summarizes the main findings of the paper, including the formation of supramolecular networks on BP surfaces and their potential to passivate the surface for over three months. They note that this is the first study on supramolecular disposition of molecules on BP surfaces using high-resolution AFM.

Download File

Description

Reviewer #1 criticizes the authors' claim that their supramolecular networks can passivate the BP surface and prevent degradation for up to 3 months, citing...

Technical Information

File Format: PDF
File Size: 324 KB
Pages: 12
Language: EN
Author: Wilhelmsen, Charlotte
Total Downloads: 208
Last Updated: 5 days ago

Document Overview

This PDF document about Peer Review File provides comprehensive information and guidance. Whether you're a beginner or advanced user, this resource offers valuable insights into Peer Review File.