Home › Categories › Science & Nature› Peer Review File (PDF 945 Kb)

Peer Review File (PDF 945 Kb).pdf

41467_2017_BFncomms14887_MOESM3003_ESM.pdf

Preview of Peer Review File (PDF 945 kb)

🔗 Source: static-content.springer.com

📊 Size: 945 KB

👤 Author: Faturoti, Rachel

⬇️ Downloads: 134

Summary

Reviewers comment on a paper by Wang et al. about the coupling of the tropical Pacific and Atlantic climates. Reviewer #1 finds the story convincing and recommends publication with minor revisions, suggesting the authors speculate on the correlation between MAM NTA and DJF Niño3.4 and change the color bar in Suppl. Fig. 2. Reviewer #2 recommends major revisions, suggesting the authors perform additional analysis to exclude other factors that could lead to the biennial tendency of ENSO and consider model experiments to clarify their mechanism. Reviewer #3 finds the work interesting but has concerns about the evidence, suggesting the authors clarify their methods, remove linear trends, and perform numerical experiments to show causality and mechanism.

Download File

Description

Reviewers comment on a paper by Wang et al. about the coupling of the tropical Pacific and Atlantic climates.

Technical Information

File Format: PDF
File Size: 945 KB
Pages: 20
Language: EN
Author: Faturoti, Rachel
Total Downloads: 134
Last Updated: 7 days ago

Document Overview

This PDF document about Peer Review File (PDF 945 kb) provides comprehensive information and guidance. Whether you're a beginner or advanced user, this resource offers valuable insights into Peer Review File (PDF 945 kb).